The challenge

How can we recruit migrant labour responsibly?

When migrant workers in global supply chains are recruited irresponsibly, they become highly vulnerable to precarious terms of employment and poor working conditions. In the Malaysian system, unethical recruitment practices remain deeply entrenched.  

While several services, tools and solutions for responsible recruitment have been introduced into that system, these interventions have yet to disrupt the status quo sufficiently enough to displace the norms, incentive structures and behaviours that keep unethical recruitment in place. 

Barriers to change

Two major barriers to achieving responsible recruitment have received less attention. Our Theory of Change is that addressing these barriers would contribute towards tackling the root causes of the problem:

  1. Employers and recruitment agents who have the most proximity to migrant workers—alongside migrant worker representatives and civil society and grassroot organisations—are rarely involved in the design of responsible recruitment interventions. They tend to be designated as “takers” rather than “makers” of the solutions.   
  1. The design of current responsible recruitment interventions insufficiently accounts for future environmental and social disruptions to migrant workers' recruitment and work experiences that are anticipated to unfold over the next decade. Although aware of these shifting landscapes, employers, recruiters and civil society and worker representatives face challenges in developing adaptive capacities to ensure and maintain responsible recruitment outcomes.

What does Shaping the Future of Responsible Recruitment hope to achieve?

Shaping the Future of Responsible Recruitment in Malaysia is a multi-year programme led by Forum for the Future that aims to build a future in which responsible recruitment norms and practices are systemically embedded and mainstreamed. 

Reflecting our Theory of Change, the programme convenes a unique collective of actors: employers, recruitment agents from origin and host countries, migrant worker representatives and civil society and grassroot organisations that support and empower migrant workers. Together, they: 

Undertake a collective diagnosis

of the barriers to eradicating unethical recruitment in Malaysia

Use futures thinking

to explore the implications of inaction and opportunities to act

Collaborate in designing and developing interventions

that have the potential to systemically embed responsible recruitment practices in the Malaysian system

We hope to achieve the following outcomes:
  • A collective understanding among key actors in the system of how responsible recruitment interventions targeted at Malaysia can be impactful in systemic, resilient and future-fit ways. 

  • New ways of working between employers, recruitment actors, migrant worker representatives and civil society and grassroot organisations supporting migrant workers that yields long-lasting, collaborative efforts to tackle unethical recruitment

  • Tangible prototypes for high-change impact interventions that will contribute towards deepening the transformative potential of responsible recruitment services and tools to systemically eradicate unethical recruitment practices in Malaysia.

Phase 1: Collective Systemic Inquiry (2023) 

In 2023, Forum for the Future convened a cohort of 25 organisationsrepresenting Malaysian employers, Malaysia and Nepal-based recruitment agencies, migrant worker-focused civil society organisations and migrant worker representatives—in a collective inquiry into the barriers to embedding responsible recruitment practices systemically in the Malaysian recruitment system. 

Participants worked toward a shared understanding of why current interventions are falling short: not adequately shifting norms, structures and behaviours, or not fulfilling their potential to protect workers well-being in the context of the current landscape and future disruptors.  

They also identified opportunity areas where action can be taken to enhance the impact of responsible recruitment interventions and contribute to transformative change in the system. Key to this inquiry was imagining the future, to lay the foundation for a subsequent phase of delving deeper into specific barriers and experimenting with design.

Phase 1 insights: blog series

Read our blog series sharing our learnings from Phase 1 on the nuances of taking a system-change approach and the deep relational shifts required for just and regenerative value chains.

Phase 2: Collaborative Design Lab (2024 – 2025 ) 

In 2024 2025, the cohort worked together in a Collaborative Design Lab to create two intervention concepts with the potential to lift barriers to deeper, more systemic embedding of responsible recruitment practices:

  1. A Risk Register tool to enable employers and recruitment agencies to jointly identify and collaborate in mitigating business-related barriers to responsible recruitment;   
  1. Two Capacity-Building mapping tools that enable capacity-builders to design training and services on responsible recruitment that are more responsive to the diverse set of needs, motivations and challenges that Malaysian businesses face:
    • A categorisation of Malaysian employers by business-type and how this influences their response to responsible recruitment and capacity-building. and likely response to support; and
    • A map that indicates the different growth stages that employers experience as they adapt their operations to responsible recruitment, and how their capacity-building needs change accordingly.
Find out more about the concepts
Risk Register Tool

Download

Employer-Responsive Capacity Building

Download

Who’s involved

The programme involves a unique constellation of participating organisations representing actors who engage closely with workers as their employers, recruiters, advocates and support systems.  

This community has become adept at holding a meaningful collective inquiry into complex, deep-rooted challenges and trusting each other to experiment with new ways of addressing them. 

We are also grateful for the participation of Aziz Ahammout, Bhim Shrestha (Executive Director & Co-Founder, Shramik Sanjal), Foo Yen Ne (Independent Consultant, Onward), Matthew Kasdin (Independent Consultant), and Yvonne Khor (PhD candidate and Program Consultant, Forum for the Future).​

Our role

Forum for the Future designs and facilitates the processes that support the participants in undertaking collective inquiry and to collaborate in designing and testing possible ways to systemically embed responsible recruitment norms and practices.

What's next

The next phase of the programme could involve further developing the intervention concepts and field-testing to assess their actionability and scalability.  

We are also conceptualising a Sensing for Resilience network, an initiative that would create regular, structured applied futures sessionsfor Malaysian employers, recruitment agents, migrant worker representatives and civil society organisationsto collectively identify landscape shifts that could impact migrant workers, consider implications and explore anticipatory responses.  

Get involved

If you're interested in getting involved in the programme, be it developing the intervention concepts or Sensing for Resilience Network, please get in touch with Sumi Dhanarajan, Managing Director, Southeast Asia.  

Contact us